My Review of the Movie “The Martian”

I just saw the movie, the Martian last night.  I did not think that I would be able to see it this soon but someone from NASA Ames gave me a ticket an hour before the show so I went for it.  As someone who designs space systems whom many of you who read this know, you might expect me to dig into and be critical about flaws in the technical details of the movie.  Not going to happen.

To me, if one word was required to describe “The Martian”, it would be beautiful.  Interestingly, earlier in the day I had seen an image from Mars, taken by the Curiosity rover.  It is reproduced below.  When you blow it up and look at it on the screen, Mars is beautiful, in the Death Valley kinda way, and The Martian captures this beauty perfectly.

An Image of the Beauty of Mars from NASA's Curiosity Rover.
An Image of the Beauty of Mars from NASA’s Curiosity Rover.

Compare this to a picture I took in Death Valley a few years ago.

Death Valley from Altitude
Death Valley from Altitude

I love to go 4×4 ing in the desert.  To be out where you can look for miles and see nothing but sand, rocks, and mountains, to look up in the sky at the starkly beautiful stars at night.  That is where I was at when watching The Martian.  I could imagine myself driving the rover, sitting on top of the ledge where Mark was above where the encampment was, on the ridge where he was walking while on his drive.  There were times while on his drive that Mark laid underneath the rover or leaning up against the front wheel.  In the movie when he was driving at night, you could see the stars in the film, brilliantly providing a backdrop for his driving.  I spent two seasons with NASA’s Desert RATS team in Northern Arizona, with their rovers, habitation units and other toys and it brought back those memories.  All of it was beautiful.  here is a picture of the NASA rover in Arizona driving on the red dirt on a lava flow that I took in 2009.

NASA's Surface Exploration Vehicle at Desert RATS 2009.
NASA’s Surface Exploration Vehicle at Desert RATS 2009.

Then for Mark himself, as played by Matt Damon, it was perfection.  He understood his predicament.  Little commented on by others but it was three days after the accident before Mark started thinking beyond his doom and started planning to live.  He was methodical, and like Robinson Cruso or Tom Hanks on the island with the soccer ball, he had to find ways to keep himself company.  Hilariously, and as in the book, it was with old 70’s sitcoms and disco music.

Indeed the entire movie was understated emotionally, at least until the end.  The NASA people, even in violent disagreement, did not come across as drama queens.  In terms of tone I liken The Martian to be like the 1969 movie “Marooned“.  (Check the link).   However, in The Martian, you did not get the over dramatization that characterized that movie or a lot of other Sci-Fi epics where people are in danger and everyone gets hysterical.  That lack of over dramatization was refreshing.  They also did not drag out the scenes of danger excessively.  Thank God in heaven that Peter Jackson did not do the movie with that running in the ground drawing out of the cinematographical drama.

At the end, the drama was greater as one would expect, and it was done well.  The sort of postscript that is not in the book but worked well in the movie was extremely well done and provided a rounding out of the story that was extremely satisfying.

All in all my favorite Sci-Fi movie in a long time.




8 thoughts on “My Review of the Movie “The Martian”

  1. Just saw it myself on Sunday night, and I agree with your assessment. Having “read” the book already (audio), I was a bit underwhelmed with the narrative of the movie (clinically observing how they crammed it all into 2.3 hrs) but blown away by the sheer majesty of it all. I suspect that this will mark the dawn of a “new age” of entertainment that treats “space” with this level of technical authenticity. We had hints of this with Gravity and Interstellar (not to mention 2001), but I think this movie finally bridges the gap between entertainment and realism. Which makes it all the better that this movie is killing it at the box office.

    And kudos to NASA for scheduling their “liquid water” announcement to coincide with this release. I sincerely hope they will reap a windfall of fresh engineers from this in the near future.

    I wish they had done something to address the radiation issue, but even the book “handwaves” that with a few words, so I’m not going to kvetch much.l I’m just happy to see a *gorgeous* movie with a great story line, in which “I’m going to have to science the shit out of this” is the one-liner summary of the whole film.

    Well played… 😉

  2. Likewise I enjoyed the movie. I forgave Weir the opening scene after I learned he posted the book on his blog, chapter by chapter. What was done was done. And later in the book he made really good drama out of a real Martian storm. The movie-makers had an opportunity to correct the error and they chose not only to run with it, but to emphasise it. Minor point. The most important takeaway are those words that deserve to become immortal: Duct tape is magic and should be worshipped. Live long and prosper. We are technorg.

  3. Saw the movie, read the book beforehand. My non-science spouse even enjoyed it because it followed a human story in Matt Damon’s portrayal, but also, the step-wise problem-solving was a joy to watch.

    There’s something so much more rich about implied drama versus overt drama. The flick was a nice combo of Castaway, Apollo 13, and 2001, in terms of tone – low key, plodding, constant tension meshed with hope. So refreshing compared to the science fiction of our time (JJ’s Star Trek or Prometheus to name a couple). But the Martian differs from other sci-fi tales in the plausibility realm. And that’s what makes it so intriguing.

  4. The book was outstanding, and I daresay the movie did the book and author justice. Wind/Sandstorm aside, the realism of the book and movie was extremely well done. The biggest challenges to overcome on Mars are radiation and the low atmospheric pressure. The presence of water flowing on the Mars surface is a huge discovery. The thought of terraforming an area at the deepest points in valleys across Mars near the equatorial line is thought provoking. Obviously these areas would have to be enclosed and protected. In any case, a very thought provoking movie that should generate a lot of interest in a manned mission to the planet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s